Kelly The Kitchen Kop

Vaccine Decisions

August 28, 2009 · 29 comments

If you're new here, you may want to subscribe to my RSS feed or free email updates. Thanks for visiting!

vaccine

Below you’ll find a list of all past posts on the vaccination issue. (More will be added later, I’m only just gettin’ goin’.)

But first, please read this important information:

Do not make your decisions about immunizations based on what you read here.  Take everything into consideration, yes, but do not rely totally only on what I share with you, because there is way too much that I don’t know.  I’ve done a good bit of research on this issue, enough that I can put a few sentences together and you may think I’ve got a solid handle on it, but I’m not even completely confident with our own decisions, let alone wanting to direct others – it’s all too confusing with valid arguments on each side to ever know for sure.  (I often think maybe we should’ve refused to have our kids get any vaccines after all.)  Use what you read here to motivate you to do more research on your own.  I’ll tell you what decisions we made after a LOT of reading and research, but do not blindly follow what we did.  Ask your doctor, read books, devour websites (Google “immunization safety” and you’ll have enough to keep you busy for hours), and get both sides of the argument so you can make an informed decision on what is best for your child and what sets right with you.  As with almost every topic, especially a hot one like this, there are just as many opinions “for” shots as there are “against”. I will not tell you what to do, and I wouldn’t want you to listen to me if I did – as I say all the time here on the blog:  doubt me!  Doubt everyone.  Ask questions.  This is your child. Even though it’s difficult and time-consuming, start the research process yourself. Let these posts be a starting point…

PAST POSTS ON VACCINATION DECISIONS

photo:  AJC1

Check out the new KITCHEN KOP REAL FOOD INGREDIENT GUIDE: only $5!

DON'T MISS NEW POSTS:

Subscribe in a reader
or Subscribe via e-mail for free blog updates.


Learn more from the COMMENTS BELOW - join the conversation!

{ 1 trackback }

Sputnik Sweetheart » shots all around!
08.28.09 at 1:06 pm

{ 28 comments… read them below or add one }

1

Cara@ Health Home and Happiness 08.28.09 at 8:30 am

I really wish it was easier for parents to come up with non-drug-company-influenced information. My research (I was all for vaccines until this) consisted of statistics, I skipped almost all the opinions. Statically I couldn’t reasonably prove that vaccines helped more than they hurt. Yes, I could gather tons and tons of opinions on either side, but real case studies and numbers are what convinced me. (my children have never received vaccinations)

Thanks for bringing up this subject! I too would love to cover it, but just don’t have the time to do it as throughly as I think it needs to be done.

[Reply]

2

Betsy 08.28.09 at 8:50 am

Cara, I read an anecdote on my fitness forum the other day that would tend to support your research. A woman said that her four kids were sick and she suspected whooping cough. She doesn’t vaccinate, so this was not a shock to her. A woman down the street from her has kids who also have whooping cough – and they’re vaccinated! Things that make you go hmmm, eh?

The doctors told her it was post-nasal drip. Oy. They wouldn’t even entertain the possibility of whooping cough until she told them that other kids in the extended family had tested positive. They had just returned from a family reunion.

I’m glad I don’t have to worry about this now; my only child is 37! When he was a baby I vaccinated without a thought. But there were fewer vaccinations then. I don’t know about the crap they add.

I do worry about the H1N1 vaccine, though, and hope that they don’t try to make it mandatory. They’ll have to drag me kicking and screaming to jail first.

[Reply]

3

Beth 08.28.09 at 11:16 am

Kelly,

I’m in such a quandry with my about-to-turn-14 yr old. She hasn’t caught chicken pox naturally because everyone is getting the vaccine. There were some locals with cknpx posted last spring but it was right before contests our dc had spent months preparing for so I didn’t persue it (should’ve). I don’t want to give her an unnecessary vaccine that was made just to line someone’s pockets (as opposed to tetanus which I do give – ugh), but it’s my understanding that if they get cknpx later it’s dangerous. She’s about at that age. Of course so many that are getting the vaccine will very likely get it later also, or continue with boosters. I think in one local school about 11 dc came down with it even though every one of them had been vaccinated.

(sigh)
Beth

[Reply]

4

KitchenKop 08.28.09 at 11:27 am

Beth, I wonder about that very thing and hope someone else chimes in who knows more. I’m hoping our youngest *will* get it naturally, but if not, I’m not sure what to do.
Thanks,
Kelly

[Reply]

5

Jeanmarie 08.28.09 at 2:20 pm

Kelly, I’ll delve into this, thanks. FYI there is an excellent, balanced, in-depth article on vaccines in the (current) July-August issue of Mothering magazine. The writer interviewed people on all sides of this issue, more in the context of routine vaccination programs for children than the swine flu issue, but it’s one of the most thoughtful pieces I’ve seen on this topic. She doesn’t come to a blanket conclusion one way or the other but gives some very good points to think about when considering each vaccine individually. It’s really worth looking at, no matter what your take on the issue. I don’t know whether it’s available on their website or not but the magazine should still be on newsstands.
Cheers,
Jeanmarie

[Reply]

6

Cara 08.28.09 at 3:04 pm

Chickenpox- it’s my understanding that you can still get shingles (which can have complications) later in life, even if you have had chicken pox as a child. Also, when I was doing research it appeared that the chickenpox vaccine only provided immunity for a few years, so someone would need to get a ‘booster’ every few years of their life if they wanted to do it that way. I also remember reading that the whooping cough vaccine was only effective for one year, and we don’t get boosters for that every year. And one link real quick, because it’s so often said that ‘it’s been proven that autism isn’t caused by vaccines’. The study was flawed that they site.
http://www.whale.to/vaccine/stott.pdf

(Kelly, feel free to delete my comment if I’m coming across too bossy! Sorry! I’m just passionate about this stuff)

[Reply]

7

jon w 08.28.09 at 4:50 pm

Kelly,

Can you elaborate on why the MSNBC article made you want to vomit? Did you feel the author misrepresented the research? Or that the research itself is bad? I won’t be getting a flu shot unless I see a lot more evidence that it works or that the new flu is bad; however I can’t find a problem with Medlock and Galvani’s basic epidemiological model, or with the report on it. They don’t attempt to address whether the new flu strain will become more virulent, or whether vaccination is too dangerous, only what would be the optimal way to distribute vaccines for best effect.

From the abstract:
“we determined optimal vaccine allocation for five outcome measures: deaths, infections, years of life lost, contingent valuation, and economic costs. We find that optimal vaccination is achieved by prioritization of schoolchildren and adults aged 30 to 39 years. Schoolchildren are most responsible for transmission, and their parents serve as bridges to the rest of the population.”

As I’ve said before, reading your site has opened my eyes to the fact that vaccines make money just like any other drug, and so there is a conflict of interest when the same companies making money are also lobbying and funding research to support their product. But I just dont see that angle in this particular article.

[Reply]

8

Jen 08.28.09 at 4:52 pm

I recently saw an ad in a magazine for a vaccine for shingles!

[Reply]

9

KitchenKop 08.28.09 at 7:56 pm

Cara, bossy works for me. :)

Jon, instead I should’ve said that it makes me want to FIGHT, because that’s what I’ll do if they try to give it to *my* school aged kids. I just see this push coming and my fear is that they’ll try to make it “mandatory”. That’s all.

Kelly

[Reply]

10

Jeanmarie 08.28.09 at 8:10 pm

I don’t have a problem with there being a shingles vaccine; my elderly uncle had shingles before he died a few years ago and it was very painful and miserable for him. However, I strongly object to forced vaccinations, especially of children, especially for multiple vaccines at once, or for unproven ones like the proposed swine flu vaccine. I also object to the typical portrayal of people who question, merely question, vaccines in general or a particular vaccine, as being nutcases who reject all medicine etc. As the Mothering article points out, people who decline to get vaccinated or to vaccinate their children are more likely than average to be well educated, and their ranks include many doctors. There no doubt is misinformation about vaccines floating about, but it’s not all on one side.

[Reply]

11

Motherhen68 08.28.09 at 8:53 pm

There is a vax for shingles as my mother’s received it. I swear, she hears out my arguments against vaxs, and she goes to the doctor and he pushes them, and she agrees. I should go WITH her to the doctor’s and fight them off LOL.

This forced swine flu vax is freaking me out. My kids are in school this year and I’m very afraid they will give them the shot without my authorization. Swine flu was rampant here last spring and all I’ve been hearing about is “swine flu swine flu swine flu”. It’s ridiculous!

[Reply]

12

Beth 08.28.09 at 9:50 pm

When I saw a news article recently about the military preparing to assist the health officials with the swine flu vaccine administration I freaked out inside. I imagined the military dragging us to get the vaccine, lol. The implications of the matter are still freaky (I won’t get into that!) but I realized after reading another article later about where they will be distributing and have been having drills that they are anticipating mob-like behavior from people WANTING the vacs… So that’s fine with me; I’ll sit this one out!

What I can see happening in the schools is that even if a parent has it written on the forms and the teacher/administration is respectful of that, in the chaos of the vaccine day a child might accidentally get put in line, get the shot, and later they would say, “Oops, sorry.” The child needs to also be aware and able to say “No shot, call me mom or dad.”

Beth

[Reply]

13

Sara 08.29.09 at 10:18 am

I too, am disheartened at the lack of independent studies on the subject. I have heard so many conflicting opinions on the link between vaccines and autism. I have now heard that they’re thinking the link to the growing autism rate is due to more and more inductions using Pitocin due to the idea (have no idea how many if any studies have been done on this) that autistic kids seem to have a lower oxytocin level because of the over-exposure during labor. We personally have only given our kids the tetanus shot, and not until they turned 2. Personally, I think research and education are key to making any decision, whether it is to vaccinate or not, or whether to accept pitocin for non-medically necessary inductions. Again, I don’t remember where I read the info, but when I find it back, I’ll post it here for you to see.

[Reply]

14

hillary 08.29.09 at 12:24 pm

It’s such a tough and personal decision. I feel like I would have to dedicate my life to wading through the information and even then would I totally get it…I’m not sure.

I’m relying more on intuition for these decisions. I read as much as I can handle and then take a deep breath. What feels right for my family, for my children.

I do wish it was more black and white, but I also trust that this phase of humanity will unravel into a deeper understanding of health for future generations (if we ever do sort this out.)

[Reply]

15

KitchenKop 08.29.09 at 2:52 pm

Hillary,

I couldn’t agree more, it is a VERY tough and very personal decision. My research often left me more confused than anything.

Kelly

[Reply]

16

Ashley 08.29.09 at 10:29 pm

Kelly,
I didn’t read all of the comments, but if you haven’t heard I wanted you to know. Matt Lauer is interviewing Dr. Wakefield. He is the doctor who found strains of the measles in the guts of 12 of his autistic patients. It is coming on Dateline tomorrow night 8/31/09 at 6:00 central time. I’m not 100% sure when my ds (5 yrs) bowel problems started, but I do remember somewhere around 12 months I had to carry extra pants with me everywhere we went. His stools were soooooo loose! At his 2 (thimersol) month and 4 (thimerosol) month shots in Africa his leg swelled, he wouldn’t let me touch anywhere near the shot wound, and he screamed high pitched squeals for about 8 hours. I also had 4 rhogam shots with thimerosol. I have had 2 girls here in America one didn’t have any reactions to vaccines. My third had high pitched squeals at her 4 month shots just like my ds. We stopped vaccinating at 6 months. Oldest child now has severe GI issues and is a little hyper boy with really bad handwriting…doing well in other areas. Girls are both doing fine. I have one friend who had a normal baby and the night of her 6 month shots started having seizures. She is now 4 years and has awful seizures that haven’t stopped and she has very little speech. The government said if they signed papers that they wouldn’t sue they would pay for medical treatment for the rest of her life. My heart goes out to that family!!! OOps didn’t mean to go on and on…although I could about this topic!! lol

Ashley

[Reply]

17

Ashley 08.29.09 at 10:36 pm

I’ll add one more thing….my friend also had the rhogam shot and the flu shot while she was pregnant!! I’m so scared for the pregnant mama’s who will be talked into the swine flu shot by their docs!

[Reply]

18

KitchenKop 08.30.09 at 10:04 am

Ashley, that is SO sad. For your son, have you read the GAPS posts??
http://kellythekitchenkop.com/2009/08/gut-health-101-6-questions-and-answers-about-a-strong-immune-system-and-the-gaps-diet.html

Thanks for sharing your story!
Kelly

[Reply]

19

Ashley 08.30.09 at 4:06 pm

Yes, Kelly…we had our ds on the gaps diet for 9 months. He did very well on it. We had to take him off b/c of transition. My husband won’t let me put him on it full time again b/c it’s too hard on our family. I think I might do GAPS part time. Right now I’m doing lots of broth and he takes really good probiotics, but I need to add in some coconut kefir as well.

Thanks for all of your hard work on this blog…it has helped me sooo much!

[Reply]

20

Kyle 08.30.09 at 5:44 pm

Thank you so much for giving us this information. I don’t think I’ll let my kids get very many shots (maybe a few) when I actually have some kids. Hopefully by then, things will be better. I realized just recently that I don’t like to talk about things like this too, because I could be wrong, and I don’t want to be responsible for somebody getting a serious disease.

Oh, and I thought I’d let you know, my brother died a couple weeks ago (he was 15, a few years younger than me, and my best friend). That really made me want to change things, to spread the truth about nutrition. They gave him so many pills, and while some pills might have helped, a lot of them seemed like they were well-let’s-see-what-this-pill-does pills. He never wanted to take those pills, or get shots, but he didn’t have much of a choice. He complained about them all the time. I think rejecting the pills was something is body was instinctively telling him. It made me sad when they put him on a non-fat diet, and everything they did was just against everything I’ve learned. But the doctors loved him too, they promised that they’d get him through this. They did their absolute best, and I can’t begrudge them for that. You believe in God, right? I do too, and I don’t know what I’d do if I thought his death was the end, but it’s not.

Anyways, thanks for listening, and thank you so much for your site!

[Reply]

21

KitchenKop 08.30.09 at 9:24 pm

Hi Kyle,

I am filled with sadness for you right now, but at the same time I’m in awe of your beautiful faith, and your rock solid belief that you will see your brother again. You surely will, and right now he must be so proud of you and your amazing attitude. I’m sure you are right – that the docs only wanted to help him, but yes it’s so sad that they just don’t know about real food yet – but your blog, mine and others will keep doing what we can.

I’m glad to know you’re a believer, and that you will lean on Jesus to help you through the grief process. When my Dad died, I learned that grief is a strange beast…you never know when it will hit you full force – every day is different.

Hang in there, and I’ll be praying for you.

Kelly p.s. Thank you for telling me. I feel like I know you from all your comments in the past months! :)

[Reply]

22

Kyle 08.31.09 at 1:33 pm

Thanks so much Kelly, again, you’re completely right :)

[Reply]

23

Darcie 10.07.09 at 2:54 pm

Hi Kelly –
I just came across your site the other day when searching for a healthy hot chocolate recipe for my 3 boys. Thank you sooo much for all the research you do. I am 13 weeks pregnant with our 4th child and have been convinced that I wouldn’t get the H1N1 vaccination under any circumstance. However, it IS concerning to know that pregnant women are dying at a rate of 6x higher than others getting the swine flu. Do you have thoughts about why that is? I take a probiotic from Dr. Mercola every day, we take echinacea and elderberry. Any other things you think I should do to defend myself this fall/winter?
Thanks!!!!

[Reply]

24

Jeanmarie 10.07.09 at 4:18 pm

Darcie, add fermented cod liver oil to your daily regimen. Most of us are short on A and D, which fight infections and cancer respectively and are so important for the immune system. You can get FCLO at http://www.drrons.com/ or http://www.greenpasture.org/.

I just made a pot of garlic soup with homemade chicken stock to help me get over a lingering “almost sore” throat. That should help with anything!
Cheers,
Jeanmarie

[Reply]

25

KitchenKop 10.07.09 at 9:49 pm

Darcie, good advice from Jeanmarie, and you can look through more immune building suggestions here: http://kellythekitchenkop.com/category/immune-system-building

Sorry, I haven’t looked into the issue of pregnant women being in a higher risk group, but I’d be very nervous getting a shot of anything while pregnant, not knowing how it could affect the baby.

Kelly

[Reply]

26

Beth 10.07.09 at 11:10 pm

Darcie,

I heard on the news (briefly) that it had to do with the pressure on the lungs from the baby but I haven’t looked into it further. I just googled and found this quote from a mainstream media (CNN) article:

“Still, the apparent disproportionate impact of H1N1 on pregnant women is not surprising, given the body changes that occur during pregnancy, she said.

“As the uterus grows and pushes the diaphragm up, there is less room for the lungs,” affecting a woman’s ability to breathe, she said.

Pregnancy’s impact goes beyond structural; it affects the body’s ability to fight off illness, she said.

“A pregnant woman has to accommodate this foreign body of the growing fetus, so there is an immunological shift that occurs in pregnancy,” she said.

Don’t know if that helps or not.
Beth

[Reply]

27

Rebekah 11.17.09 at 5:45 pm

Kelly,

I am a little more than 6 months pregnant with our first baby. I have just started doing a little research about vaccines. Any chance your post about which vaccines you opted for and against will be forthcoming soon? I know it’s a personal decision but it would be sooooo helpful to have guidance from some other mothers who have already walked this road!

Thanks!
Rebekah

[Reply]

28

Kelly the Kitchen Kop 11.17.09 at 8:28 pm

Rebekah, congratulations!
I’ll try to move that one up the list and get it done in the next two or three weeks. Once I post, hopefully it will spark a lot of good conversation that will be helpful for you. In the meantime, do some Googling! :)
Kelly

[Reply]

Leave a Comment

You can use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Older post:

Newer post:

Clicky Web Analytics