I’m ashamed to say we used to be a pretty heavy fast food family. There were periods of time when we’d think nothing of “grabbing something quick” 2-3 times per week! I can’t believe now how stupid we were – nobody should be that busy (or lazy). I pray that we didn’t somehow tarnish our oldest son’s health with all that junk. (Read about what a “fast food” meal is for us these days. It’s not that difficult, I promise!)
How it all began
I’ve always been blessed with being able to eat pretty much whatever I wanted and not gaining weight. Well, just as I was warned by many, in my mid to late 30’s that all began to change. I decided it was time to drop 10-15 # and began the South Beach Diet that I’d heard about.
So many contradictions…
I remember reading that book and being very frustrated by how much the author contradicted himself. He’d say it was the wrong carbs (or too many) that caused weight gain and that it wasn’t the good fats that were the problem, only the bad fats – I still believe all that. But then his recipes in the back would call for reduced-fat cheeses, low-fat sour cream, “egg substitutes”, or “I can’t believe it’s not butter” of all things! (YUCK!) He did the same thing with sugar. He’d say we should keep it at a minimum, but that natural sugars are best because they have a low-glycemic index and are way less processed/refined (if at all). He explained how the artificial sweeteners are full of chemicals that we just don’t know enough about yet to determine if they’re safe, not to mention how unnatural they are – I still believe all that. Then his recipes would call for a “sugar substitute” or sugar-free jello and puddings!
My “nutritional mentor” got the ball rolling faster
Toward the beginning of this diet I spoke with a neighbor friend, Kathy, who is very knowledgeable on health-related issues (more than I’ll ever be!), and she suggested that information in this book may not be correct, (click here for why not to do the South Beach diet). She gave me a website to check out, and the next morning I woke up early and sat reading on that site for a couple hours straight. What I read changed something inside me, there’s no other way to describe it. It was full of information I had not heard anyplace else at that point (but I hear it more and more now – word is spreading), and it all made so much sense!
For just one example, I read about good fats and thought, “No wonder people try to lose weight for years on these low-fat diets and it is a constant up-hill battle that many never win!” (Unless you are among the super-disciplined, who can fight your own body as it tries to tell you what it needs.) It told how we need good fats for every function in our bodies and how it’s only the fats that have been introduced in the past few decades that are killing us (margarine, unhealthy vegetable oils: corn, sunflower, soybean, cottonseed, canola/rapeseed, safflower, and all trans fats), NOT the fats that people have been eating forever on their family farms! (Butter, eggs, whole milk and dairy products, meat from healthy animals…) That’s just ONE of the topics I delved into that morning, and it was only the beginning. My teenager had no idea at the time how his life was about to change forever.
I became a wild-woman in my kitchen
Starting that day I became a label reader. I weeded out the junk from my pantry and freezer. We bought new pans and got rid of any aluminum or Teflon. I started making much more of our food from scratch, and even annoyed my friends and family like crazy with all the new information I wanted to share. (More about that in future posts.) I delved into everything probably a bit faster than most, and became very overwhelmed at times for two main reasons:
- When I was just beginning to cook healthier and learning all this new information, the list of the things I found out I was “doing wrong” grew like crazy. Whether it was the food I was buying, the way I prepared it, or the pans I cooked with, the more I learned, the more overwhelmed I became and the more I wanted to change – I can’t believe the many things I’d just never even heard were unhealthy!
- The other frustrating thing was that I’d find out something was unhealthy and switch everything out in my kitchen, only to find out later I’d gotten some bad scoop and what I’d switched TO was also unhealthy! It was difficult finding the truth, which is why I hope this site is the helpful resource to you that I wish I’d had in early 2004.
If you’re wondering about the diet results…
By the way, I modified the diet based on what I began learning and I lost 11# in a week and a half by eating plenty of healthy fats, very limited amounts of healthy carbs (no white bread or pasta), good protein, and lots of veggies, too. It’s been about 4 years since then, and I’m not always good about eating a limited amount of only healthy carbs (I still love sweets too much), but I do eat liberal amounts of healthy fats and my weight has stayed pretty normal. (I only see a little weight come on now and then if I do get too heavy on the carbs in my diet, but then I’ll watch it for a week or two and it will come back down.)
My advice:
You will probably want to take all this a little slower than I did and not change so much in such a short period of time. Not only to save the budget, but also to save your sanity!
- Does fat make you fat?
- Life Changes - Five Ways They’re All the Same
- I’m really not a food snob!
- Trans fat dangers
- Book suggestions on dieting, nutrition & more
- Cod liver oil helps with dieting, because when your body is getting what it needs, it doesn’t need to hang on to the extra fat in fear that it won’t get anymore – it’s how our bodies are made, to conserve when we’re not getting enough of something…
- Have you heard of Weston A. Price?
- Tips on getting EXERCISE into your life
- Coconut oil kick-starts your metabolism - read about where to get it
- Are supplements necessary for good health?
LEAVE A COMMENT BELOW and tell about your “food conversion”!
Check out the new KITCHEN KOP REAL FOOD INGREDIENT GUIDE: only $5!DON'T MISS NEW POSTS:
Learn more from the COMMENTS BELOW - join the conversation!






{ 1 trackback }
{ 10 comments… read them below or add one }
Anonymous 09.03.08 at 2:06 pm
Wow…I didn’t know all of that about the South Beach Diet. Go figure. It promotes itself as a healthy, veggie-full program. The word “diet” turned me off. And, Sally Fallon’s work turn me straight to what’s good.
Thank you, Kelly, for giving me the short version of the SBDiet. I’m going to forward it to my friends. Sheesh. Chemicals, low fat and not enough good fats….same ol’ same ol low fat dogma that has ruled out press for 30 years. I hope people wake up to what doesn’t work so they can find out what does! I’m down 21 pounds myself…yahoo. Even better, my mental health is astronomically better.
Hugs and thank you for working so hard on our behalf.
Karen in Merida, Yucatan
karenferguson@compuserve.com
Kelly the Kitchen Kop 09.03.08 at 4:35 pm
Karen,
Great job on the weight loss!!! And even better is the improved mental health – priceless.
Thanks for commenting!
Kelly
Vera 01.11.09 at 3:18 pm
Years ago we used to buy SBD protein bars. Then recently I saw the ingredients list at the supermarket. Soy..soy…more soy… And corn syrup. And hydrogenated oils. And they say that stuff is good for you! Gross.
TrailGrrl 01.31.09 at 6:49 pm
Every time my sister goes back on SBD she loses a bunch of weight and then gains it back even worse. I think you really can’t believe that smashed up cauliflower is any substitute for real mashed potatoes made with butter and cream.
I used to to Body for Life and have probably tried every high-end protein drink, meal replacement, and bar that is out there. It worked for a while, but let’s face it, the food is all processed.
When I hit 40 things just changed. My tolerance for carbs I think went way down, and it took more work to stay fit. I stopped processed foods and upped my natural fats from meats and other sources. I see the word “soy” and in my mind I think “crap.” I originally got to WAPF by reading Ross Enaimit’s boxing forum. Ross is extremely well built and muscular yet with washboard abs and he doesn’t do any protein powders or artificial foods. He got all his info from the WAPF forums. I started to take what they were saying more seriously then.
I can’t even eat the bars that are just made with fruit and nuts anymore (larabar, clif nectar, etc.) because they are just too sweet for me now that I have returned to real food. Traveling in Europe and eating local foods but not gaining any weight makes you realize how much garbage is being sneaked into our foods in the U.S.
TrailGrrl
Kelly 01.31.09 at 11:41 pm
Wish I could get to the point where sweets were “too sweet” for me…can’t imagine it!
Char Young 04.15.09 at 11:49 pm
Hi Kelly,
My husband (www.catholicfoodie.com) found your site & I’m just skimming through your posts. He found it through Lisa H. Anyway, so glad to have found you & I’m really looking to reading more. From what I’ve read so far, it seems we’re on the same page with food philosophy. We converted to whole foods 2 years ago. (I think I need to read up on the aluminum & teflon though.) I have become much more relaxed with the kids when we are away from home, but keep things here as strict as possible. That said, my house is full of traditional Easter candy at the moment—ugh! I must let the “grands” do their grandparenting thing!
Kelly 04.16.09 at 1:55 am
Hi Char, fun to hear from you, tell hubby thanks for spreading the word for me! I hear ya on the candy thing…tomorrow it starts to mysteriously disappear……..
Jeanmarie 07.31.09 at 7:58 pm
Kelly, I’ve been reading your site from time to time over the past few weeks and really delved in today. I appreciate you sharing your story. I stumbled upon Nourishing Traditions at a Whole Foods Market in about 2004 and it changed my life. I’ve been doing it much more slowly than you did. When I first read NT for some reason I skipped the whole first section on basic nutritional information, WAP-style, and started reading recipes, but everything seemed to require me to make something else first, so it was frustrating and confusing. Then I saw a demo by Sandor Katz on making sauerkraut and started with that, then made kombucha, then kefir, and still ate processed crap far too often. But living on a farm the past year, and growing my own veggies the past few months without a job, I’m getting close to 100% nonprocessed food. I get a lot of fulfillment making my own food, not just a meal, but foundational foods like bone broth and lacto-fermented veggies (and fruits!). Perusing your site and similar ones has really helped keep me excited about all this lately, so thank-you! I’ve put on a few pounds (from cheating on store-bought ice cream etc.) and am paring back carbs now to get in fighting shape, so thanks for the inspiration.
KitchenKop 08.03.09 at 11:37 am
Hi JeanMarie,
Wow, almost 100% non-processed, that is awesome! Wish I could say that! I’m glad the site has helped you. Keep commenting, I’d love to hear more from you.
Kelly
Dana 08.24.09 at 11:32 am
I didn’t know about that SBD article at the WAPF site. Thanks for sharing it. I already didn’t like the diet because the first time I picked up the book at somebody’s house and leafed through it I thought Agatson was buying into mainstream dogma. I’d already read Atkins at that point and done my own homework, you see. (Dr. Atkins really liked Nourishing Traditions, by the way. *smile* If you don’t use any of the Atkins products and just follow the original diet it relies *heavily* on real foods and saturated fat.) What really infuriated me was the love affair the press was having with the SBD on account of its creator being a cardiologist. Duh? Atkins was one too.
Anyway. Thanks for sharing your story… I still have a long way to go.